POM’s ‘The Hall of Fame Toastie’ Wants a Hot Dog to Join Hockey’s Greatest Legends

POM's The Hall of Fame Toastie campaign celebrating Montreal's iconic toasted hot dog

In 2016, the Florida Panthers travelled to Montreal to play the Canadiens. After the game, the team found pizza waiting for them. Normally, that wouldn’t make headlines. Except Montreal’s arena hot dogs are legendary. According to Sports Illustrated, the players were furious. Their rookie equipment manager had apparently ordered the wrong food, and it took a long time for the team to forgive him.

That’s quite a reputation for a hot dog to have.

But Montreal’s famous toasté has been part of hockey culture for decades. Now, POM wants to give it something even bigger: a place in the Hockey Hall of Fame.

POM's The Hall of Fame Toastie campaign celebrating Montreal's iconic toasted hot dog

A hot dog with a history of its own

The Montreal toasté, also known as a toastie, is wonderfully uncomplicated. It’s a hot dog in a bun grilled until golden and buttery on both sides. Nothing particularly extravagant. Just a simple, messy snack that has become part of the hockey experience.

Its following goes well beyond the home crowd. Former NHL star Luc Robitaille has recounted how Wayne Gretzky once gave the Los Angeles Kings’ equipment manager money to bring back 48 Montreal hot dogs for the team.

The toastés were already a fixture at Montreal’s old Forum. When the Canadiens moved to their new home in 1996, even the grill used to prepare them reportedly made the journey.

For a snack, that’s quite a legacy.

Over the years, these hot dogs have become a ritual for home fans, visiting players and journalists. They’re the sort of thing people plan their intermission around. Sporting traditions have a way of creating memories that go far beyond the game itself, much like Star Sports’ #BillionCheers campaign, which celebrated the spirit of Indian sports fans. And apparently, Montreal’s toasties are memorable enough to cause disappointment when someone gets the food order wrong.

The most unexpected Hall of Fame candidate

So, if the Hockey Hall of Fame exists to recognise hockey’s greatest legends, why shouldn’t a snack that has been part of the game for generations get a nomination?

That’s the thinking behind “The Hall of Fame Toastie,” a campaign by POM Bakery and Cossette Montreal.

There’s a natural connection between the campaign and the brand behind it. POM stands for Pride of Montreal, a name that feels particularly fitting for a product so closely tied to the city’s hockey culture. Its famous toasted POM bun is an essential part of what makes the Bell Centre hot dog the Bell Centre hot dog. It’s a brand with Montreal pride built right into its identity, helping build an icon for fans across the league.

The campaign takes this connection and turns it into an actual petition asking the Hockey Hall of Fame to recognise the local favourite.

The creative approach is to treat the nomination with all the conviction of a genuine hockey debate. There’s a serious institution, a candidate with decades of history and a case to be made. The only difference is that this particular candidate has never scored a goal, made a save or spent a minute in the penalty box.

That’s precisely where the humour comes from.

Taking Montreal’s case to Toronto

There’s another detail that makes the campaign even more entertaining.

The Hockey Hall of Fame is in Toronto, home of the Maple Leafs and one of Montreal’s biggest rivals. So POM isn’t simply asking for recognition of a local tradition. It’s taking Montreal’s case straight into rival territory.

And the brand doesn’t have to manufacture a connection to hockey culture. The toastie already has one. The Athletic has written about its place as a cherished tradition for visiting teams, Sports Illustrated has documented the dressing-room pizza disappointment, and NHL media celebrated the toasties’ return to the press box in 2021.

The folklore was already there. POM and Cossette Montreal simply found a new way to put it in the spotlight.

Now, the campaign is inviting fans, players and anyone who has ever eaten a toastie with one eye on the scoreboard to sign the petition.

The Hockey Hall of Fame usually celebrates people who have changed the game. But this little hot dog has gone undefeated during every intermission.

It’s already a legend in Montreal. POM just thinks it’s time to make it official.

Cast your vote: HallOfFameToastie.com